If you need enquiries in the next month, start with PPC (Google Ads). If you can wait three to six months and want something that keeps working without paying per click, start with SEO. Most local businesses end up running both, using what the ads teach them to decide what to rank for.
Here's how fast each works, what each costs over a year, and when each is the wrong choice.
The basic trade-off
Google Ads is fast. A well-built campaign can put you at the top of the page within days. The moment you stop paying, you disappear.
SEO is slow. It usually takes months before new pages rank well enough to bring in steady enquiries. But a page that ranks keeps working without you paying for each click, and the work builds on itself. Each good page makes the site a little stronger for the next one.
So ads buy speed, and SEO builds something you own. Most businesses want both eventually. The question is where to start.
Start with ads if you need enquiries soon
If you've just opened, just moved, or have a quiet diary next month, waiting four to six months for SEO isn't much help. Ads can fill the gap while the slower work happens.
Ads are also a fast way to find out what works. Within a few weeks you'll know which searches bring enquiries, which bring tyre-kickers, and roughly what an enquiry costs you.
Use the ads data to decide what to write
This is the part people miss. The search terms report in Google Ads shows the exact phrases real customers typed before they enquired.
That's the best keyword research you can get, because it's tied to actual enquiries rather than a tool's estimate. If "same day boiler repair" brings in jobs and "boiler installation cost" brings in people who never call, you know which page to write first.
We run SEO and Google Ads together for exactly this reason: the ads tell us which terms are worth the slower, more expensive job of ranking for. There's more on how that works on our SEO and PPC page.
When ads are the wrong choice
When nobody is searching. Ads only show when someone types a matching search. If you've invented a new kind of product, or you sell something people don't know to look for, there's no search to appear against. You'd be better off with other channels.
When the budget is too small to learn. For most local businesses, around £750 a month in ad spend is a sensible minimum. On much less, you get so few clicks that it's hard to tell what's working. We cover this in more detail in how much Google Ads management costs.
When the clicks are very expensive and the jobs are small. Some trades pay a lot per click. If one job is worth £60, the sums may never work.
When SEO is the wrong choice
When search volume is tiny. If only a handful of people a month search for what you do in your area, ranking first might bring one enquiry. That can still be worth it for a high-value service, but often it isn't worth a monthly retainer.
When you need results this month. SEO won't deliver that, and anyone who says it will is overpromising.
When the website itself is the problem. If the site is slow, confusing or doesn't say what you do, sending more people to it doesn't help either channel. Fix the site first. Our website audit is a good place to find out whether that's you.
What each costs over a year
A worked example using our own prices, for a local business with a modest budget. Your numbers will differ, but the shape usually holds.
| Google Ads (PPC) | SEO | |
|---|---|---|
| Setting up | £600 first month (account, tracking, first landing page) | £900 audit, credited against the work |
| Monthly fee | £300 a month after the first | From £750 a month |
| Paid to Google | Around £750 a month in ad spend, the sensible minimum | Nothing per click |
| Year one total | Around £12,900 (£3,900 in fees, £9,000 in spend) | Around £9,000 |
| When enquiries start | Within weeks | Usually three to six months |
| If you stop paying | Enquiries stop the same day | Rankings fade slowly |
So in year one, ads cost more and deliver sooner. SEO costs less, starts slower and keeps working into year two and beyond. That's why the question is usually about order, not choice.
Running both, and shifting the money over time
For many local businesses, the best answer is both, in a particular order:
- Start ads on your most profitable services, with proper tracking and a landing page that answers the search.
- Use the search terms to choose your SEO pages. Write for the phrases that brought real enquiries.
- Watch those pages climb. When a page starts ranking well for a term, you can often reduce what you spend on ads for that same term.
- Move the budget towards the services that don't rank yet, or towards new ones.
Over a year or so, the ads become the thing that covers gaps and tests new services, while SEO carries more of the steady work.
Our view
If you need enquiries soon and there's clear search demand, start with ads, and use what they teach you to plan the SEO. If you can wait, the market is competitive, and the budget is tight, a focused piece of SEO work may be the better first spend. If the search volume is tiny, we'll say so, even if it means neither.
Have a look at our Google Ads and SEO pages, or Google Ads in Leicester if you're local to us, or get in touch and we'll tell you which we'd start with in your position.

